Saturday, January 23, 2010

No. 1 Threat...BEARS!!!

Actually, only one Bear...Bear Grylls. I've always enjoyed the show "Man vs. Wild", but the most recent episode staged in Montana really made me question the "reality" of the show. Also, I've always known a camera man accompanied him on his adventures and that there are emergency crews on stand by.

This time though, too many things seemed too conveniently "found" exploring Big Sky Country, such as a metal chain on a wooden brace in an old mine shaft (he used it to make a grappling hook to climb over a concrete wall 100 feet above the ground!), a half downed out of service telephone pole (he used the telephone wires to create a zip line to traverse a valley!), and the most coincidental of 'em all, a half submerged canoe just off shore in a huge lake (which by the way, he patched up the hole and made a kite with his parachute to "surf" across the lake!). To top it all off, the viewer actually sees that he has a crew with him this time as they run through a tunnel to beat a train. Conveniently, the camera man is located at just the right spot outside the tunnel to catch Bear jumping out towards the camera man just as the train shoots out of the tunnel.
Even considering these examples, I am willing to accept the faux reality that is created because he does have a substantial knowledge of outdoor survival skills and provides a halfway entertaining hour of outdoor adventure. Check it out and let me know what you think.

Ciao

2 comments:

Eileen said...

I've never been a big fan of "Man vs. Wild." I think "Survivor Man" is much more realistic and interesting.

Eric said...

Watching MvW from time to time, it definitely seems to be skewing more towards entertainment than survival. The best example would be the fact that Will Farrel was on for an episode. More or less, I'd guess about 50% of what Bear goes through is staged. I'd also argue that it seems to be going the Fear Factor route and having him eat something gross once and episode.

In any case, I'm trying not to watch a significant amount of TV, and sorry to say for Bear's sake, MvW doesn't make the cut.