Thursday, November 12, 2009

Nuclear or not nuclear

Nuclear talks have been all the rage lately. I just wanted to do a "grassroots" poll to see where you guys sit. Are you for new nuclear plants or against?


Now, I will add a caveat to this. If you are for new nuclear plants, then one would be built within 50 miles of your home. If you are against new nukes, you have to make a rational suggestions for an alternative.

I won't throw in my opinion at this time, but will follow up once everyone says what they think. I will however add that there aren't any wrong opinions, and that I've heard every extreme, so considering our group's level of intelligence, I'm sure what you think is pretty valid overall.

4 comments:

Mike said...

I'm pro-new-nuclear, though I do wish someone would come up with a better recycling/disposal program for spent fuel.

I worked at Point Beach for 8 months and lived within 10 miles of the plant. I even got to go into the containment area where I was maybe within 100 feet of the reactor. The safety regulations are ridiculous. I felt quite safe there and that was a 40(?) year old plant. Though it's not a given, I would think a modern plant would be safer.

The only time I was worried for my safety was when a guard was standing in a urinal next to me with his ak-47 hanging across his body and pointed in the general direction of my junk.

Phoenix said...

Awesome comment Mike! From some things I've read and heard, it seems that Nuclear is a cleaner and cheaper energy. However, I've seen a lot of costs not associated with the generation of the energy is made up by the necessary waste management/containment. Let's look at the scale tipper for me...Sim City. Remember how one Nuclear Power Plant would do the job of 4-5 Coal Plants! I rest my case.

LKc said...

I agree w/ both above...esp wrt finding better recycling/waste alternatives. I'm surprised nuclear energy isn't more prolific now being more efficient than other alternatives--I assume the cost to build is more risky and harder to get community support??

teledildonics said...

I pro-nuke. Can we just throw the waste on top of Iran or at the very least, New Jersey?